WHL Commissioner's Stark NCAA Comparison: Is it Business Class of Hockey?

WHL Commissioner's Stark NCAA Comparison: Is it Business Class of Hockey?

hockey Jul 17, 2025

A simmering debate lies at the heart of professional hockey’s future, and it never truly vanished. WHL Commissioner Dan Near reignited it with some bold words that struck a chord with hockey fanatics and insiders alike.

A Comparison That Stings

Appearing on the Pipeline Show podcast, Near didn’t mince words when making a dramatic analogy that rang through the corridors of hockey discussions. Describing NCAA hockey as akin to flying “business class,” he questioned if this path leaves players unprepared for the gritty, demanding world of the American Hockey League (AHL).

Critics Rise in Defense

The reaction was swift and fierce. Many advocates rallied behind the NCAA, presenting its focus on development, education, and holistic growth as equally valuable. Some voiced the view that Near’s critical comments were ill-timed given Gavin McKenna’s high-profile transition to NCAA hockey—a pioneering move under new eligibility norms.

Turbulent Paths to NHL

The ultimate question hanging in the air is Dan Near’s assertion: Can NCAA’s cushioned environment truly prime athletes for the pro leagues’ raw realities, or does it cocoon them in comfort? As stated in Times of India, opinions remain sharply divided, especially as a growing number of CHL players eye the collegiate route.

The Never-ending Debate

Despite the ongoing skirmish between NCAA loyalists and AHL enthusiasts, there’s common recognition that no singular route ensures success or entry to the NHL’s elite. The debate reflects deeper anxieties and expectations within the sport: a relentless drive for competitive advantage.

Looking Past the Horizon

As the leagues grapple for future NHL stars, the echo of Near’s comment resounds, promising no smooth glide but a challenging ascent. The NHL’s doors await those who can navigate their chosen path steadfastly, whether it’s business or coach.

Embark on this compelling narrative and reflect on the varied paths weaving their way to hockey legend. The route to greatness, like life, isn’t ‘one size fits all’—and that’s what keeps fans on the edges of their seats.

Tags